UK equities climb to all-time highs as Sunak faces general election wipeout

The sun is setting over 10 Downing Street

Broad measures of UK equity performance like the FTSE UK RIC Capped Net Tax Index have posted record levels in the wake of local elections.¹ The last on-the-ground test of political sentiment in the country before the general election only confirmed what polls have been predicting for a while now: Prime Minister Rishi Sunak’s Conservative Party is heading for a crushing defeat, some five years after winning a historic majority. When former Prime Minister Boris Johnson pushed through a snap election at the end of 2019, his promise to “get Brexit done” carried the Tories to the largest Conservative majority since Margaret Thatcher. Of course, a few COVID lockdown parties and poor staff choices later, “Bojo” was forced to step down and Liz Truss took over. Lasting just 50 days, her premiership was the second-shortest since 1721, the year that Sir Robert Walpole become the country’s first de-facto prime minister.² While Rishi Sunak’s tenure has been free from major scandals, after 14 years of Tory rule, the country seems to be yearning for change.

The Labour Party maintains a huge lead in the polls of around 20 points, or 44%,³ leaving chances of another Tory majority unlikely. Given that the government has some flexibility in setting the general election, Sunak’s best bet could be to push the date back as far as possible—in this case, January 2025. This would allow more time for some of his key pledges to materialise, namely taming inflation, stopping illegal immigration across the English Channel and cutting National Health Service (NHS) waiting times.⁴

Ultimately, however, the prime minister appears to be left with no good options.

Economic policy differences may play out at the margins

The question is whether any of these considerations matter to the markets. We think that more likely than not, we believe the upcoming campaign and election outcome will be of limited significance. Compared to the United States, policy differences between the main parties remain moderate. The political turmoil around Brexit has mostly settled, and the issue has lost much of its ideologically divisive power. Labour might try to foster stronger trade relations with the European Union (EU) but finds itself similarly constrained by the rules Brussels has set. Labour leaders have said that there are no plans to hike income taxes;⁵ Conservatives are pushing for lower taxes, but economic realities dictate that any cuts would have to be marginal. Energy giants might face a more structured approach to windfall taxes, but in practice, Tory governments had implemented these levies on at least three occasions since the days of Margaret Thatcher.⁶ In summary, while there are obvious policy differences, their economic impact may play out at the margins.

Most likely, markets have already at least partially priced in a Labour win. Either way, the United Kingdom is in dire need of economic growth.

Diversification benefits at attractive valuations

Both Brexit and the pandemic have had a disproportionate impact on the country’s economic trajectory compared to its G7 peers. In real terms, the UK economy today is only 1% larger than its pre-pandemic level. With the exception of Germany, which has experienced virtually zero growth, this is the weakest performance among its G7 peers. By contrast, the United States has seen an increase of more than 8%, while Canada and Italy have each grown by roughly 4%.

The current year is also shaping up to show lacklustre growth, placing the country near the bottom of the range. However, looking ahead, the International Monetary Fund predicts that the United Kingdom will grow closer to its long-run potential, at an annual rate of between 1.5% and 2%, and is expected to add a cumulative 8% to its gross domestic product (GDP) between 2025 and 2029.⁷ This would position the country at the higher end of the G7 growth spectrum. Investors seeking to add targeted allocation to the UK market may find single country exchange-traded funds to be a cost-effective vehicle for exposure.

It is also noteworthy that core exposures to UK equities are only partially at the mercy of domestic economic performance. The FTSE UK RIC Capped Net Tax Index comprises large- and mid-cap stocks, including some of the top financial institutions, global players in consumer goods, and two of the world’s largest energy companies. Since 2020, it has outperformed the more domestically oriented FTSE 250 Index by almost 25 percentage points. Meanwhile, it has significantly lagged other large-cap indices, like the S&P 500 or the global FTSE Developed Index. But in times of the “Magnificent Overconcentration” of a handful of stocks and the IT sector, we think that UK equities can offer an interesting complement to investor allocations. Besides the diversification angle, there is also a valuation argument.

With a price-to-book ratio of less than 2.0, UK equities are currently trading at a discount of more than 50% compared to US equities. Additionally, in terms of forward price-to-earnings, they are closely aligned with emerging market levels. Furthermore, the United Kingdom has long been considered a haven for income investors, and it currently boasts a dividend yield of 3.8%.⁸